Poor Communication Is Killing Your Culture: How to Rebuild Trust with the 5Y Framework

Bottom Line Up Front (BLUF):

In today’s overloaded workplace, communication is more frequent but less effective. Leaders and culture champions must evolve their communication strategies or risk disengagement, poor performance, and cultural collapse.

This article explores:

  • Why communication breakdowns are so costly (and common).
  • How the 5Y Framework can address miscommunication at its root.
  • A real-world case study of what happens when leadership gets it wrong.
  • Clear, actionable steps to improve clarity, trust, and team alignment.

If you’re navigating change, leading a transformation, or trying to energize a disengaged workforce, this is your playbook.

The Problem: Communication Overload, Culture Undermined

We’ve all seen it—frustrated teams, disengaged employees, and projects that never quite stick. And while it’s easy to blame strategy, market conditions, or lack of resources, there’s usually a quieter culprit hiding in plain sight:

Poor communication.

Despite having more tools, meetings, and message threads than ever before, workplace communication is breaking down. Not only is this harming productivity, but it’s also eroding trust, morale, and long-term business outcomes.

Knowledge workers now spend 88% of their workweek communicating across multiple channels. Yet, most feel overwhelmed, under-informed, and unsure of how to best share or receive information. According to the 2024 State of Business Communication report by Grammarly and The Harris Poll, over half of professionals feel anxious about misinterpreting written messages, and nearly one in three report decreased confidence due to poor communication.

Meanwhile, AI holds massive promise—up to $1.6 trillion in annual productivity gains—but remains underutilized because most teams lack clear communication workflows or training to apply it effectively.

The communication problems we’re seeing in the workplace aren’t symptoms of operational dysfunction; they stem from emotional misunderstanding. Especially during times of change, a lack of clarity can create fear. And fear kills performance.

As a leadership and workplace culture advisor, combat veteran, and consultant to organizations navigating transformation, I’ve developed the 5Y Framework to help leaders and culture champions bring clarity, empathy, and consistency to their communication, so that teams feel supported, not blindsided.

The 5Y Framework for Communication That Builds Culture

1. Yardstick (Yourself): Define and Align the “Why”

You can’t lead others with clarity if you haven’t first achieved it within yourself. Communication starts before the words leave your mouth—it begins with internal alignment. When leaders speak without a clear “why,” their message feels disjointed, creating confusion, hesitation, anxiety, and distrust.

The Yardstick is your internal compass. Ask:

  • Why are we communicating this now?
  • What values are we reinforcing?
  • What outcome do we want on the other side?

Example: Before announcing a team restructure, be clear: Is this about efficiency? Innovation readiness? Strategic alignment?

Action Tip: Write a one-sentence purpose statement before any significant message. Use it to test every element—tone, timing, medium, and structure.

2. Yield (Your People): Engage Before You Explain

Too often, communication in leadership becomes a one-way broadcast. But people don’t resist change because they’re incapable—they resist when they feel excluded or unimportant.

People support what they help shape.

Yield is about participation before the presentation.

  • Ask questions before making announcements.
  • Invite feedback early and visibly.
  • Treat communication as a dialogue, not a directive.

Example: Before announcing a shift in remote work policy, invite employees to provide feedback on what flexibility means to them and what challenges they foresee.

Action Tip: Establish a feedback loop within your communications process. Use surveys, skip-level meetings, or team listening sessions to gather insights before implementing significant changes.

3. Yare (Your Culture): Make Communication Easy

“Yare” means agile and ready. However, most workplace communication systems are slow, fragmented, and frustrating. When communication is difficult—overly complex, inconsistent, or buried—people tend to disengage. That disengagement is the start of cultural decay.

Making communication “yare” means:

  • Simplifying language. Drop the jargon.
  • Standardizing channels. Don’t make people guess where to find info.
  • Reinforcing key messages in multiple ways.

Example: A high-growth startup replaced scattered Slack threads and lengthy emails with a weekly 3-bullet memo from leadership and consistent department huddles. Team alignment soared.

Action Tip: Audit your communication channels. Where are the bottlenecks? Where are people tuning out? Create a Message Map for each initiative to ensure clarity and consistency.

4. Yoga (Your Impact): Flex Your Style, Not Your Standards

Effective communication doesn’t mean you must change the message for every person—it’s about knowing how to meet people where they are while still moving them forward. In emotionally charged environments, flexibility is your superpower. Some need clarity. Others need reassurance. Great leaders know how to offer both.

Yoga is about being emotionally adaptive without sacrificing core direction.

  • Use video + written comms for sensitive updates.
  • Match your tone to the emotional temperature of the team.
  • Balance fact with empathy.

Example: A product team facing launch delays received a direct video message from their VP acknowledging their effort, followed by an email with clear next steps. The combo approach boosted morale rather than eroding it.

Action Tip: Map your stakeholders. What do they need—urgency, inspiration, reassurance? Flex your format and tone without losing the clarity of your message.

5. Yearn (Your Legacy): Communicate Like It’s Being Remembered

Your legacy isn’t what you leave behind—it’s how people experience your leadership right now. Every meeting, email, or message adds to your leadership brand. Especially during hard times, how you show up communicates more than what you say.

Yearn is about showing up with intentional impact:

  • Speak with integrity—even when the message is tough.
  • Be present—not just performative.
  • Leave people feeling seen, not just spoken to.

Example: A CEO personally called five laid-off employees to thank them for their contributions. It didn’t change the reality, but it changed how those employees remembered their time with the company.

Action Tip: Before hitting “send,” ask:

  • Would I be proud of this if it were read aloud to my team?
  • Am I demonstrating respect and building trust, even in uncomfortable situations?

Case Study: When Communication Fails

A mid-sized SaaS company—let’s call it TechCo—faced a significant decline in sales due to enterprise budget cuts. The leadership team decided to lay off 20% of the staff. But instead of strategic, human-centered communication, they defaulted to corporate coldness:

  • News leaked via Slack before leadership addressed it.
  • The internal memo was vague and lacked context.
  • No space was provided for dialogue or emotional support.

The result was that trust collapsed. High performers started job hunting. Clients asked questions. And those who stayed began quietly disengaging.

What could’ve changed the outcome using the 5Ys:

  • Yardstick: Start with a clear, values-driven “why” behind the layoffs.
  • Yield: Involve people leaders in planning support strategies before rollout.
  • Yare: Use multiple, consistent channels to communicate.
  • Yoga: Tailor tone and medium for different stakeholders.
  • Yearn: Reach out directly, express gratitude, and offer dignity.

Poor communication fractured the culture. And the ripple effects will linger for years.

Closing Thought

If your communication isn’t intentional, it becomes incidental. Incidental communication—especially during change—can invite confusion, fear, and disengagement. The 5Ys are your blueprint for cultural clarity.

Let’s Talk:

What’s the biggest communication challenge your organization is facing right now? Drop it in the comments or send me a direct message.

For Organizations:

If you’re leading a change initiative, rethinking culture, or navigating the return-to-office conversation, let’s explore how BrightMind Consulting Group can help you implement the 5Y Framework through training, consulting, or workshops.

Visit brightmindcg.com or reach out directly to start building a culture where clarity is the standard—not the exception.

Article content

Jevon Wooden, MBA, ACC💡, CEO and Founder of BrightMind Consulting Group, is a speaker, trainer, certified coach, and business consultant. He specializes in empathetic leadership, emotional intelligence, and workplace culture. A U.S. Army veteran and Bronze Star recipient, Jevon is the author of From Functional to Phenomenal: The Entrepreneur’s Guide to Transforming Your Leadership and Business, where he introduces his 5Y Framework for clarity, confidence, and sustainable growth and Own Your Kingdom: How to Control Your Mindset, So You Can Control Your Destiny. His work has been featured in Entrepreneur, Forbes, Inc. Magazine, and Fast Company.